Retargeting Strategies for B2B: Converting Website Visitors into Leads

For B2B companies, the majority of website visitors are not ready to convert on their first visit. In fact, research shows that only 2-5% of website visitors convert on their first visit. This is where retargeting becomes essential—a powerful strategy that allows you to reach the 95-98% of visitors who did not convert the first time.

This comprehensive guide will show you how to build effective retargeting strategies that convert website visitors into qualified leads.

Understanding Retargeting

What is Retargeting?

Retargeting (also known as remarketing) is a form of online advertising that can help you keep your brand in front of bounced traffic after they leave your website. When someone visits your site but does not convert, retargeting allows you to show ads to them as they browse other websites.

Why Retargeting Matters for B2B

The B2B Challenge:
– Longer sales cycles
– Multiple decision-makers
– Complex evaluation processes
– Higher value conversions

Retargeting addresses these challenges by:
– Maintaining brand awareness
– Nurturing prospects through the funnel
– Increasing conversion rates
– Maximizing ad spend efficiency

Types of Retargeting

Site-Based Retargeting

Targets people who visited specific pages on your website.

Segmentation Options:
– All visitors
– Specific product/service pages
– Pricing page visitors
– Demo request page visitors
– Blog readers
– Contact page visitors

Search Retargeting

Targets people who searched for relevant keywords but did not visit your site.

Use Cases:
– Competitor keyword targeting
– Category keyword targeting
– Solution keyword targeting

Email Retargeting

Targets people who opened or engaged with your emails but did not convert.

Integration:
– Connect email platform with ad platform
– Target email list members with ads
– Segment by engagement level

Building Your B2B Retargeting Strategy

Step 1: Define Your Audiences

High-Intent Audiences:
– Demo request visitors
– Pricing page visitors
– Contact form completers
– Free trial sign-ups

Medium-Intent Audiences:
– Product/service page visitors
– Case study readers
– Webinar registrants
– Blog engagers

Low-Intent Audiences:
– General website visitors
– Homepage visitors
– About page visitors

Step 2: Set Up Conversion Tracking

Essential Conversions to Track:
– Demo requests
– Quote requests
– Form completions
– Content downloads
– Email sign-ups
– Phone calls

Step 3: Create Custom Audiences

Audience Definition:
– Time-based segments (7-day, 30-day, 90-day)
– Page-specific segments
– Action-based segments
– Engagement-based segments

Retargeting Ad Strategies

Awareness Stage

Goal: Increase brand familiarity

Ad Types:
– Display ads
– Video ads
– Native ads

Messaging:
– Brand storytelling
– Industry thought leadership
– Educational content

Frequency:
– Lower frequency (2-3x per week)
– Broader audience

Consideration Stage

Goal: Educate and nurture

Ad Types:
– Case study ads
– Comparison guides
– Product information

Messaging:
– Problem-solution content
– Social proof
– Feature highlights

Frequency:
– Medium frequency (3-4x per week)
– Targeted audience segments

Decision Stage

Goal: Drive conversion

Ad Types:
– Conversion-focused ads
– Limited-time offers
– Retargeting with special incentives

Messaging:
– Clear calls to action
– Urgency and scarcity
– Risk reversal (guarantees, trials)

Frequency:
– Higher frequency (daily)
– High-intent audiences only

Platform-Specific Strategies

Google Ads Retargeting

Audience Options:
– Standard remarketing
– Dynamic remarketing
– In-market audiences
– Customer match lists

Best Practices:
– Use responsive display ads
– Create custom combinations
– Exclude converted customers
– Set frequency caps

LinkedIn Retargeting

Audience Options:
– Website visitors
– Contact list uploads
– Company engagement

Best Practices:
– Use sponsored content
– Target by company size
– Focus on decision-makers

Facebook/Instagram Retargeting

Audience Options:
– Website traffic
– Engagement audiences
– Customer lists
– Lookalike audiences

Best Practices:
– Use carousel ads for content
– Test video retargeting
– Leverage lead gen forms

B2B-Specific Retargeting Tactics

Content Nurturing

Strategy:
– Retarget blog readers with related content
– Show relevant case studies
– Promote webinars based on interest

Example:
Visitor who read “Manufacturing ERP Guide” → Retargeted with “ERP Case Study: 40% Efficiency Gains”

Product Education

Strategy:
– Target product page visitors with feature education
– Show comparison content
– Highlight use cases

Example:
Visitor who viewed “Industrial Equipment” → Retargeted with “Equipment Selection Guide”

Demo Follow-Up

Strategy:
– Retarget demo requesters who did not convert
– Show success stories
– Offer consultation alternatives

Example:
Demo request visitor → Retargeted with “Customer Success Story: Similar Company Results”

Measuring Retargeting Success

Key Metrics

Reach Metrics:
– Audience size
– Frequency
– Reach percentage

Engagement Metrics:
– Click-through rate
– View-through conversions
– Cost per engagement

Conversion Metrics:
– Conversion rate
– Cost per lead
– Return on ad spend

Attribution Considerations

View-Through Attribution:
– Credit for conversions from ad exposure
– Important for brand awareness campaigns
– Set appropriate attribution windows

Common Retargeting Mistakes

### Mistake #1: Broad Audiences
Create specific audience segments for better targeting.

### Mistake #2: No Frequency Cap
Too many ad exposures lead to fatigue and negative brand perception.

### Mistake #3: Generic Messaging
Create specific ads for each audience segment.

### Mistake #4: Ignoring View-Through
View-through conversions often represent significant value.

### Mistake #5: No Exclusion Rules
Exclude customers and converted leads from retargeting.

Conclusion: Retargeting as a Revenue Driver

Retargeting is not just an add-on to your marketing strategy—it is an essential component that can dramatically improve your conversion rates and ROI. By reaching the visitors who did not convert on their first visit, you can turn lost opportunities into qualified leads.

Start with clear audience segmentation, create relevant messaging for each stage, and continuously optimize based on performance data.

—

Ready to build your retargeting strategy? At Story Agency, we help manufacturing and industrial companies in the Southeast develop retargeting strategies that convert. Schedule a consultation to learn how we can help you maximize your advertising ROI.